Skip to content
Altcoins

Cardano Treasury Vote Fails: DReps Reject 22M ADA Copper Reserve Plan With Only 0.51% Yes

A plan to spend 22 million ADA from the Cardano treasury on US warehouse copper expired with 0.51% DRep support. How the vote went and why it failed.

Trading since 2017. Futures, onchain data and automation. 3 min read
Cardano treasury vote banner: a forklift backs a pallet of copper plates tagged 0.51% YES away from a shut blue vault door
Cardano treasury vote Base Camp

The short version

  • Cardano treasury proposal “Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve” expired on November 15 with 0.51% DRep support, far short of the 67% it needed.
  • It asked for 22 million ADA, about $3.4 million at the time of writing, to buy copper in a US warehouse and tokenize it on Cardano as CuTT.
  • All three constitutional committee votes were no, so the 22 million ADA stays in a treasury of about 1.43 billion ADA.
  • Next: two more treasury withdrawals, AURORA and PFMS, expire at 21:44 UTC on Friday, November 20 unless DReps back them first.

0.51%. That is how much of Cardano’s voting stake backed a plan to turn 22 million ADA from the Cardano treasury into copper plates sitting in a US warehouse.

It needed 67%.

This Cardano treasury withdrawal, called “Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve,” expired when epoch 668 began at 21:44 UTC on Sunday, November 15 (4:44 p.m. in New York). Five delegated representatives (DReps) voted yes. 126 voted no. Those 22 million ADA, worth about $3.4 million at the time of writing, never left the treasury.

So was it just a bad trade, or did it break the rules as well? The people who vote on Cardano’s money say both.

SIPO, a Japanese stake pool operator and DRep, posted the final tally in Japanese on Monday:

📡Signal|銅の戦略備蓄の国庫案 2,200 万 ADA、DRep 賛成 0.51% で失効

国庫から 2,200 万 ADA を引き出して米国の倉庫の銅を買う提案「Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve」が、期限のエポック 668 を迎えて失効しました。

DRep の賛成は 0.51%(5 票)で、可決の基準 67%

View on X

What Was the Cardano Copper Reserve Plan?

A one-time payment of 22 million ADA to Toto Finance, a US company, to buy copper and tokenize it on Cardano.

Toto Finance would buy COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes, store them in a COMEX-approved US warehouse and issue a token for them on Cardano. Each token, called CuTT, would stand for one pound of copper.

Only part of the money was for metal. Toto’s proposal put 14.72 million ADA, about 67% of the request, into copper. Another 2.64 million ADA went to Toto Finance’s own technology and project management, and the rest to operations, audits and an independent administrator nobody had hired yet. The copper would be held for 18 to 24 months, sold, and the net proceeds sent back to the treasury by month 36.

No return was promised. Toto said itself that neither the ADA nor any copper gain was guaranteed.

For context, the Cardano treasury holds about 1.43 billion ADA, roughly $218 million, according to Koios on-chain data. The copper plan asked for about 1.5% of it.

Sponsored · Affiliate link

Save 20% on fees trading on WEEX

Base Camp may earn a commission if you sign up. It never affects what we write.

How Badly Did the Cardano Treasury Vote Fail?

About as badly as a Cardano governance vote can. By stake, 20 million ADA voted yes and 2.86 billion ADA actively voted no, the on-chain governance record shows.

Cardano treasury vote tally: 20.0M ADA yes (0.51%), 2.86B ADA voted no (72.31%), 131.3M no confidence, 943.1M did not voteCardano treasury vote tally: 20.0M ADA yes (0.51%), 2.86B ADA voted no (72.31%), 131.3M no confidence, 943.1M did not vote
DRep vote Koios

On a treasury withdrawal, Cardano counts active DReps who stay silent as a no, together with stake parked on the automatic “no confidence” option. Abstentions drop out of the sum. In other words, even if every DRep who skipped the vote had switched to yes, the plan would have topped out around 24%.

It wasn’t only a Cardano DRep vote, either. The constitutional committee, which checks every action against Cardano’s constitution, cast three votes. All three were no.

Committee member Tingvard listed three problems in its published rationale. Toto’s proposal document sat on an ordinary website that could be changed after submission. Toto Finance was its own administrator, with every independent check still to be appointed. And the address receiving the ADA was delegated to a stake pool. “Each of these defects is sufficient on its own,” Tingvard wrote.

SIDE TRAIL: Zcash Vote Opens Nov 16: Coinholders Weigh Pulling 50,000 ZEC From the Grants Treasury

ADA Price After the Copper Vote

ADA price chart ADAUSDT daily on Binance at $0.1529, below the 50 and 200-day MA, between $0.1808 resistance and $0.1486 supportADA price chart ADAUSDT daily on Binance at $0.1529, below the 50 and 200-day MA, between $0.1808 resistance and $0.1486 support
ADAUSDT Chart 1D Binance

The vote didn’t move ADA. The market did. ADA trades at $0.1529 at the time of writing, down 1.0% in 24 hours and 12.7% over the past week, with the Fear & Greed Index stuck at 10.

On the daily chart, ADA sits far below the 50-day moving average (MA), the average close of the last 50 days, at $0.2123, and the 200-day MA at $0.2037.

  • Resistance: $0.1808. The early-November floor that gave way last week.
  • Support: $0.1486. A June swing low that ADA wicked under in the latest sell-off. Below it sits the June bottom at $0.1382.

TRAIL MAP: Support and Resistance in Plain English: Floors, Ceilings and Why They Work

Final count by stake: 2.86 billion ADA against, 20 million for, or about 143 to 1.

Two more treasury withdrawals, AURORA and PFMS, are still open, and by SIPO’s count neither can reach 67% even if every silent DRep votes yes. Their deadline is the start of epoch 669, at 21:44 UTC on Friday, November 20 (4:44 p.m. in New York).

Written by
VikingXBT

VikingXBT has been trading crypto since 2017. The focus is futures, onchain data and automation. Onchain flows get checked before a chart is trusted, and anything repetitive gets automated. VikingXBT built Base Camp's own onchain scanner, which flags bundlers, snipers, dev holdings and wallet clusters in one view, and backtests strategies before trading them.

More from VikingXBT